RE ATAR Unit 3 - differing ways in which religion is viewed in society

Context

Religious traditions interact with specific cultures in complex and dynamic ways. These interactions influence how religion is perceived and understood within society, particularly around matters of concern to religion. In a multicultural and multifaith society such as Australia, there is a rich diversity of religious traditions reflects many aspects of religion and society throughout the world. (Religion and LIfe ATAR Year 12 syllabus)

Why are young Australians Rejecting Religion?

Society

What is society? 

Society is defined as a moral unit made up of individuals associated together for a common purpose. The idea of society requires that there be union of effort on the part of all towards securing for each and every individual of the body a due participation in the common object; for, if each one seeks for himself alone, there is no moral union. The union of effort that is required must come from the deliberate intention of the members to co-operate for the common end, there must be a moral obligation to do so. The notion of society includes the idea of permanence. A society can be described as a permanent moral union of several persons for the purpose of attaining a common good by mutual co-operation. 

Governing authority is essential to direct the members in their co-operation for the common good. For, considering the uncertain and fluctuating character of human opinion and human will, it is clear that the permanent co-operation of people is impossible without a directing and co-ordinating power to harmonise the discordant elements and direct the different forces towards a common end.

Differing views of religion in society - Sources

 

The Catholic Church’s view of religion in society 

The role of the Church in society http://www.miraclerosarymission.org/hab180.htm 

 

The Christian citizens in society 

Role of the Laity in the Transformation of Society http://www.miraclerosarymission.org/hab260.htm 

 

The secular or atheistic view of the role of religion in society 

Religion has no place in Government https://www.secularhumanism.org/index.php/articles/3465 

 

Extra resources 

Does religion have a place in politics? http://www.in-debate.com/2011/10/religion-in-politics/ 

 

Some opinions for and against the place of religion http://www.debate.org/opinions/does-religion-play-a-vital-role-in-modern-societies 

 

Australian Society

Different Views

Different views about religion in society

If we are thinking about individual perspectives on religion, there are three very common and useful terms we can employ: theism, atheism and agnosticism. In everyday parlance, ‘theism’ denotes a belief in God (or, more broadly, a belief in divine or spiritual realities); ‘atheism’ denotes a conviction that there is no God (or divine or spiritual realities); and ‘agnosticism’ indicates a lack of certainty or knowledge (gnosis) one way or the other. When investigating a social or natural phenomenon, categorisation is a useful exercise. Each of these views about religion could be said to be most closely associated with one of the aforementioned outlooks (atheism, theism and agnosticism) Religion as a belief system Assumes that ultimate reality exists and religions have a basis for their beliefs. Aspects of this category include: • religions meet the spiritual needs of people • religions answer questions of meaning and purpose in life • religious transformation brings about fundamental change in people Religion as a human invention Assumes religions have no basis for their beliefs but are creations entirely of human origin. Aspects of this category include: • religion is used to manipulate people • religion is used to subjugate people • religion is a human construct to give comfort in times of distress Religion as a functional agency Assumes that religions, whether of human origin or not, are a universal phenomenon and therefore must serve a useful purpose. Aspects of this category include: • religions are organised systems that promote the stability of society • religions are good for health and wellbeing • religious ideals fulfil the need for a stable frame of reference Religion as a political entity Assumes that religions, whether of human origin or not, represent groups of people with common interests. Aspects of this category include: • religions are influential • religions have values • religions have traditions Other sets of categories can be used. For instance: religion as an authority; religion as a guardian of society’s morals; religion as a custodian of culture, tradition or ethnicity; etc. It is important to remember that when looking at these categories of religious views, they are not automatically to be assumed to be characteristic of only one of the three religious outlooks (atheism, theism, agnosticism) For example a theist and and atheist may share the view that religion is a political entity, even if they disagree on its basis in truth.

Order of Society - Church View

The nature and object of the different areas of society: 

  1. Civil society – The purpose of the State (civil society) is to secure for the people the peaceful enjoyment of their rights; and to promote morality, enlightenment, and sufficient material prosperity among all classes. The immediate aim of the State’s activities is to ensure peace and prosperity for all; for these are means essential to human (temporal) welfare, and can be secured only by the helps which the State affords. The long term goal of the state is to preserve the temporal happiness of its citizens by promoting the fuller development of their physical, intellectual and moral powers.  

  1. Social science has to do with social organisation and social activities of every kind that pertains to the welfare of the citizens of the state 

  1. Ethics. The principles of ethics relate to human actions in their moral aspect, distinguishing namely, the good from the bad, and aims at leading humanity to their last end. Ethics has to do with the deliberate actions of humans. Actions of people in society must be in conformity with ethical standards, thus social science must be subordinate to Ethics. In other words, acts for the sake of a supposed social advantage cannot run counter to sound moral principles. Ethics exists primarily to promote human temporal good. Its scope is the family and the state. The family has a fundamental importance in the life of the nation. It is the fundamental social organism and the building block of society. 

  1. Jurisprudence/Law. The purpose of the study of Law is to direct the rulers of the State in framing civil laws and regulating their administration with a view to the peace and prosperity of the citizens. Social Science which directs the different members of the State in the fulfilment of their civic duties - social co-operation towards the more perfect attainment of the ends and aims of civil society. 

  1. Political Economy refers to the human activity that is employed about the production, distribution and consumption of material goods. Social science focuses on the temporal welfare of the citizen: their social wellbeing, their material interests, and intellectual and moral development.  

 

Data

Opinions

Why should the Church be involved in society? 

The Catholic Church 

The principles connected with dignity and inalienable rights of the human person are confirmed in the strongest way by the mystery of the Redemption and the human elevation to the supernatural state. When a social system is organised on true principles, its proper working has always to meet obstacles rooted in human passions, ignorance and sin. These obstacles can be effectually overcome only by the forces of religion. Therefore society need the guidance of the Church to organise a social system in accordance with natural law principles based on right reason and harmony. 

Social justice is the Church’s concern when evils which have resulted from the disregard of civic duties, abandonment of social rights and duties, poverty and oppression of individuals or groups, the immense wealth and excessive power accumulated in the few, the injustice caused by the monopolies, the tyranny of the bureaucracy masquerading under the cloak of popular authority, the general unrest and widespread spirit of revolt; the antagonism between the rich and poor; the spead of irreligion and demoralisation caused or promoted by secular media; and other forms of injustice. Christian principles pertaining to the true understanding of human dignity help to understand and critique the issue of modern society. 

 

Church View of Society

The Family and the State are a natural institutions and society that are the result of human nature. They come into existence in response to essential human tendencies and character and to provide for needs which spring from the very nature of man. 

The immediate object of the Family and the State has to do with man’s temporal interests and their existence and scope as well as their fundamental structure, spring from the law of nature which was ordained by God in the very act of creating man. The essential principles that govern human activities can be ascertained by the light of reason (natural law).  

The Church is also a society founded by the direct intervention of God whose object is to lead people to their supernatural destiny, which is direct union with God. Its foundation and constitution depend upon God’s revelation to man. Its constitution cannot be altered or interfered with by any human authority.  

The existence and scope of their essential principles of their structure, the fundamental rights and duties of the members are determined by God’s law, but entrusted to human control (positive law).